The Broken Sword review

May 10, 2025 - Reading time: ~1 minute - Category: reviews

The Broken Sword was written around the same time as The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe and the Fellowship of the Ring, and is a foundational heroic fantasy novel, but unfortunately hasn't reached the same level of mainstream success as those novels despite being very on par in quality.

The Broken Sword blends together elements of Celtic and Norse mythology with a dash of historical fiction to create a novel that clearly influenced later writers like David Gemmell. There's larger-than-life heroes and villains, unexplained magic, mythological weapons, and tons of monologued poetry. It's not the easiest read, but it's evocative and lyrical and deserves more attention.

The first half of the novel is the stronger bit, in my opinion - the ending feels a bit rushed and descends into a pretty one-note tale of battles and slaughter that isn't as rich as the more heroic and romantic earlier acts - but this one is definitely worth a read if you're interested in heroic fantasy or sword and sorcery. It feels quite a bit like reading a myth, much like The Lord of the Rings in some ways but decidedly its own thing in tone.

Tags

books

About

My name's Mike, and this is the Lore Depository - my spot online where I can write out my thoughts on games, books, tech, history, and anything else I find interesting. 

My biggest project is my Game Library Project. I have a ton of games collected throughout the years, and have barely played any of them. Check out the linked post to learn more about the project, and click here to be taken to the category page where you can see all my posts for the project.

Other content comes mainly in 3 forms:
Reviews, where I post longer-form writeups
Thoughts, short & quick first impressions posts
Guides, detailed how-tos and walkthroughs

Click the links to go to each category's page, filtered by newest post.