The White Rose review

December 22, 2025 - Reading time: ~1 minute - Category: reviews

The Black Company doesn't have the emotional richness of Robin Hobb's work, the narrative complexity of George RR Martin's, or the sheer scale of Robert Jordan's. It's a precursor to all of them: not so epic in scope but a fantastic, well-written story all the same.

This novel concludes the initial trilogy of the series. It takes a while to get going, and has a sometimes-confusing three-part plot where it jumps across years and POVs until they converge about halfway through. But from around that halfway point it picks up and moves at a rapid pace until the end of the novel. It's a satisfying conclusion on its own while leaving a clear path open for future stories.

Many people say this series is the first real "grimdark" series. I'm not sure that's strictly true, but all the trappings are here: complex, morally-dubious characters, violence, deaths of relatively major players, and a rather grim worldview. Croaker's complicated relationship with the Lady is one of the most interesting I've read in years. It feels like a modern novel - if you told me this came out in the 2020s rather than the 80s, I'd believe you.

The Black Company books aren't a massive time investment, either. Good stuff.

Tags

books

About

My name's Mike, and this is the Lore Depository - my spot online where I can write out my thoughts on games, books, tech, movies, and anything else I find interesting. 

My biggest project is my Game Library Project. I have a ton of games collected throughout the years, and have barely played any of them. Check out the linked post to learn more about the project, and click here to be taken to the category page where you can see all my posts for the project.

Other content comes mainly in 3 forms:
Reviews, where I post longer-form writeups
Thoughts, short & quick first impressions posts
Guides, detailed how-tos and walkthroughs

Click the links to go to each category's page, filtered by newest post.